SIALIMStatistical Intelligence for America's Local Investment Markets

Metros › Indiana › New Castle

New Castle, IN Housing Market Forecast — November 2026

Typical home value $189,782 as of October 2026 · Cooling

Sialim forecasts the typical New Castle home value to fall -0.23% in November 2026, from $189,782 to $189,338, with an 80% range of $189,061 to $189,783. Over a year, the model projects $193,224 by November 2027 (+1.81%). In its latest six-month backtest, it missed by 0.3% on average.

A typical New Castle home costs 18% less than the Indiana metro median of $230,769. Over the past year New Castle values moved +3.04%, while the median Indiana metro moved +5.14%.

Last updated with Zillow data through October 2026. Share as image

Next month — November 2026
$189,338
-0.23% · range $189,061–$189,783
Quarter — February 2027
$190,104
+0.17% · range $188,330–$191,676
One year — November 2027
$193,224
+1.81% · range $189,774–$197,797
Backtest error
0.3%
avg miss, last 6 months

Blue: typical New Castle home value (Zillow ZHVI, smoothed and seasonally adjusted), last 10 years. Amber dash: forecast path through November 2027; dotted lines mark the 80% confidence range, which widens with the horizon.

Why the model sees it this way

Sialim's model forecasts the typical New Castle home value will fall 0.2% in November 2026, from $189,782 to about $189,338. The 80% confidence range runs from $189,061 to $189,783.

Prices rose an average of 0.33% per month over the past three months, and the market is up 2.9% from a year ago.

The 30-year mortgage rate sits near 7.3% (restrictive for affordability); for-sale inventory is up 25% year over year, which adds downward pressure on prices; national unemployment is 4.1%. For this metro the price-only model outperformed the macro-augmented one in backtesting, so the forecast leans on the price trend itself.

Over the most recent six-month test window, this model's predictions for New Castle were off by 0.3% on average. Smaller is better; anything under 1% is strong for monthly home values.

New Castle for investors

10-year change+112%
Annual growth, compounded7.9%
Distance from peakAt peak
1-year forecast rank#442 of 894 US · #31 of 36 in IN
Price vs median US metro-24%

Over the last 10 years the typical New Castle home went from $89,348 to $189,782, a +112% change, or about 7.9% a year compounded. Over the last five years alone, values rose 34%.

Values are at or near their high for this period ($189,782, October 2026).

The one-year forecast of +1.81% ranks #442 of 894 US metros, in the middle of the pack, and #31 of 36 metros in IN. A typical home here costs 24% less than in the median US metro.

Investing from outside the US? Read the guide to buying US property from abroad for taxes, financing and currency risk, or compare markets on the metro rankings.

New Castle people and housing

Population49,137
Population change since 2020+0.47%
Median household income$63,150
Home price to income3.0×
Median gross rent$820/mo
Gross rental yield (rent ÷ value)5.2%
Households that rent24%
Housing vacancy rate11.2%
Median age42.2
Adults with a bachelor's degree or higher18%

A typical New Castle home costs 3.0 times the median household income, which the usual price-to-income scale rates as moderately unaffordable. Rent at the median covers about 5.2% of the typical home value each year, before costs.

Census Bureau, ACS 5-year 2020-2024 for New Castle, IN Micro Area; population from Census population estimates, July 2025. Price-to-income and yield use Sialim's typical home value for October 2026.

How this compares with Zillow's forecast

HorizonSialimZillow's forecast
Next month-0.23%-0.10%
Three months+0.17%+0.40%
Twelve months+1.81%+2.50%

Both forecasts point the same direction for New Castle over the next twelve months. Zillow forecast © Zillow, shown for comparison; horizons are aligned to the nearest published month. Agreement or disagreement between the two models is a useful signal either way.

Similar-size IN metros

Marion, IN
+0.03%
next month
Richmond, IN
-0.27%
next month
Jasper, IN
+0.08%
next month
Kendallville, IN
+0.08%
next month
Plymouth, IN
+0.09%
next month
Seymour, IN
-0.22%
next month

See all IN metros →

Analyze any investment property in seconds - Sponsored

See the most expensive ZIP codes in New CastleObserved home values by ZIP, plus fastest-appreciating and best rental valueView ZIP codes →

Can I share this New Castle, IN forecast?

Yes. Post this month's forecast image with credit to this page.

For Instagram, Facebook
Monthly forecast alert

Get the new New Castle forecast in your inbox each month, plus the metros that moved most.

No spam, one email a month, unsubscribe anytime.

Tools for this market

Analyze a specific deal
Metro forecasts frame the market; deal-level cash-flow analysis closes the loop.
Run the numbers →

Some links above are partner links; Sialim may earn a commission at no cost to you. Partners never influence forecasts or scores.

Frequently asked questions

What is the typical home value in New Castle?

$189,782 as of October 2026, per the Zillow Home Value Index. New Castle homes cost 18% less than the Indiana metro median of $230,769 and 24% less than the median US metro.

Is New Castle a buyer's market or a seller's market?

About 40% of New Castle listings show a price cut, and Sialim forecasts a +1.81% change in home values over the next year. You should have room to negotiate on price.

How does New Castle compare with other Indiana metros?

New Castle's one-year forecast ranks #31 of 36 Indiana metros. Metros closest in size include Marion, Richmond and Jasper.

What is the New Castle home value forecast for November 2026?

$189,338, a -0.23% change from the latest value of $189,782. The 80% confidence range is $189,061 to $189,783.

Is the New Castle housing market cooling or heating up?

Sialim classifies New Castle as "Cooling". Prices have been slipping and Sialim's model forecasts further softness.

What is the New Castle home price forecast for 2027?

Sialim's model projects $193,224 by November 2027, a +1.81% change from today's $189,782. The 80% range is $189,774 to $197,797; year-ahead forecasts carry much wider uncertainty than next-month calls.

How much have New Castle home values grown over ten years?

+112% since November 2016, about 7.9% a year compounded. Values are at or near their high for the period.

Is New Castle housing affordable?

The typical New Castle home costs 3.0 times the median household income of $63,150 (ACS 5-year 2020-2024). On the usual price-to-income scale that counts as moderately unaffordable.

Is New Castle a good market for investors outside the US?

Its one-year forecast ranks #442 of 894 US metros. Overseas buyers should also weigh currency moves against the dollar, US withholding on sale proceeds (FIRPTA), and how they will finance and manage the property. Sialim's guide to buying US property from abroad covers each step.

How accurate is this forecast?

Over the most recent six-month test window, this model's New Castle predictions were off by 0.3% on average.

Model details

Forecasts come from Sialim's proprietary forecasting engine, which runs several competing model specifications for every metro, backtests them against what actually happened, and publishes the winner for each horizon. Trained on 211 monthly observations (2009-04-30 to 2026-10-31). This metro's market heat index reads 33, with about 40% of listings showing a price cut. See the methodology for how forecasts are built, and the ZHVI guide for what the underlying index measures.

Forecasts are model output, not advice. Data: Zillow ZHVI (© Zillow), Freddie Mac via FRED, US Bureau of Labor Statistics via FRED.